"Even Apeldoorn bellen" ("just call Apeldoorn", where the company is based). Dutch insurer Centraal Beheer has used the line since 1986. Forty years. Everyone in the Netherlands knows what it means.
Now compare that with how long a head of marketing stays. According to Spencer Stuart, a CMO at a large American company stays in the role for four years on average, and three and a half at consumer brands. Every new boss wants to leave a mark: a new story, a new campaign, a new logo. And so, time and again, something disappears that took years to get into people's heads.
The story isn't worn out
I have seen it often, and not only with new marketing directors. Clients who have been at the helm for years also find their own story worn out at some point. They get tired of telling it again and again. They simply fancy a refresh.
Understandable. You hear your own story every day: in every meeting, every presentation, every campaign. Your customers hear it now and then, between a thousand other brands. Just as you're thoroughly tired of it, it's only starting to land with them.
What you throw away
A brand lives in the associations people have with it. A colour, a line, a shape, a voice. Those associations trigger an emotion. And you don't throw that emotion away just because you want to jump on a trendy bandwagon.
Tropicana did it in 2009. The familiar orange carton with the straw made way for a sleek, modern design. Within seven weeks, sales fell by twenty per cent. The company reversed the change and admitted it had underestimated customers' bond with the old packaging. In 2024 it did the same thing with a new bottle. Sales dropped again.
In his Mini MBA, Mark Ritson told the story of Veuve Clicquot. The champagne house has used a yellow label since 1877. At some point, people wanted to get rid of it: they were tired of it. Ritson dug his heels in. Rightly so: that yellow is the brand.
Throw it away, then bring it back
As a brand enthusiast, I sometimes simply don't understand why something gets put out with the rubbish. Take "Biertje?" ("Fancy a beer?") from Heineken. Ever since ski instructor Rudi walked into a ski hut in a 2002 commercial, the whole of the Netherlands has known it. Yet it disappeared from view for a while. Dutch brand strategist Marc Oosterhout wonders about the same thing in his book Merklogica. In 2021, when bar terraces reopened after lockdown, Heineken brought Rudi back with #FirstBiertje.
MediaMarkt did something similar. In October 2025, it brought back "Ik ben toch niet gek!" ("I'm not crazy!"), its pay-off in the Benelux. MediaMarkt itself wrote that it should strengthen consistency and recognisability. With a slogan that had been around for decades, it already had both.
Who guards the foundations?
So what do you do as the person responsible for the brand when a new boss arrives who wants something new, or when the board is tired of its own story? Whether you sit in marketing or in communications, the answer is the same.
Work analytically. Look at which associations your brand has, and which of them work, before anyone throws anything away. And don't make yourself important: it's not about your mark, but about what the brand has built up in people's heads.
Don't let yourself be swept along by agencies that want to bring something new, either. That is their job, and sometimes something new really is needed. But make the boundaries of renewal clear. Make explicit which foundations you won't touch. Put it in writing, and include it in every brief.
Renewal is fine. But anyone who touches the foundations should be able to explain why. "I'm tired of it" is not a reason.
Sources:
