For three years I was chair of Logeion, the Dutch professional association for communication. Every year I attended C-Day, the association's big conference. Always a pleasant day, with decent speakers and good stories. Afterwards, the satisfaction scores were sky-high. The audience was happy.
I never quite was. Nothing chafed, nothing got uncomfortable. Mostly, we told each other how important our profession is.
As chair, I didn't decide the programme. It is put together carefully, based on research into what members want. I would have liked it to be more radical myself, but then you lose your audience. Perhaps that is the real problem: a profession that mainly wants to hear what it already believes.
I saw how it can be done differently back in 2018, at Content Marketing World, the big American content marketing conference. The rise of AI was already a major theme there. Christopher Penn, co-founder of Trust Insights, left the room deeply uneasy. His message boiled down to this: if you wanted a future in marketing, you had to start studying maths now to grasp the essence of AI and machine learning. Then it was the turn of Paul Roetzer, founder of the Marketing AI Institute. He too said you had to innovate and keep learning, but that if you did, you would always stay ahead of the rest. First real discomfort, then reassurance. That is what I always wanted for C-Day.
Both came to mind last week when I read a piece by Sharon O'Dea, digital workplace expert and co-founder of Lithos Partners.
Two rooms
Within three weeks, O'Dea sat in two rooms. In Paris, SAP told a room full of HR people that its recruiters spend 95 per cent less time on admin. The room applauded. In London, a room full of communications people spent two days reassuring itself: AI may change our tools, but no machine can take over our empathy and judgement. Better still: finally, time for strategic work.
One profession cheered work that was disappearing. The other was counting on a promotion. O'Dea calls it a cope problem: the profession is talking itself into confidence. That is a poor strategy.
I think she's right.
Good enough is enough
Her argument is economic. AI doesn't have to be better than a communications professional for you to need fewer of them. Good enough is enough. And jobs don't disappear with a bang. Nobody announces that AI has replaced three communications people. Those three simply never get hired.
I see it too. Teams are shrinking, and vacancies stay open more often.
At agencies, I also see quality eroding. There are fewer senior people, so there is less experience. Clients want everything faster and cheaper, while experienced people are used to a certain salary. Agencies are supposed to make a 15 per cent operating margin. Rik Ledder, chair of VIA, the Dutch association of communication agencies, said last year that the figures are closer to 10 per cent. If clients then also expect agencies to innovate and get cheaper, it becomes a race to the bottom. Only those with the money to fund the shift escape it.
In every episode of Accent Makers, the podcast series Dick van der Lecq made for the Dutch organisation SAN, guests were asked the same question: will AI make agencies bigger or smaller? In a sector with so many companies and people, I don't think growth in headcount is the honest answer for most of them.
That is the economic story. But I think O'Dea is right mainly for another reason.
You don't get that role, you take it
Every company is now wrestling with the question of what AI means for the organisation. Look at who is at the table when that question gets answered: KPMG, Accenture, Deloitte, the big media and advertising holding companies, IT consultancies. I hardly ever see communications people there.
Yet they could play a real role in what I call AI advisory: guiding organisations through their questions about AI. But they're not there.
That is no coincidence. I don't enjoy saying it, but communications people aren't all that innovative. Cautious and conservative, if anything. We like to congratulate ourselves on how important the human is, but many lack the ambition to develop. As long as it stays cosy in the mutual admiration society.
If you don't present yourself as a serious partner in that conversation, you won't get the role. Nobody invites you because you're so empathetic.
The ladder is broken
O'Dea points to something else. We predict a future full of senior strategists, while removing the junior jobs through which people become senior.
I ask myself that question too, and I don't have an answer. The comfortable ladder we used to have no longer exists.
I do believe real talent can still get in through a specialism. You understand influencers better than anyone, you enjoy vibe coding, or whatever it may be. But how do you learn the craft after that? My advice: learn the basics that last for decades, with a grounding in science. For me, that included Mark Ritson's Mini MBA in Brand Management. And work with AI yourself, because it always needs a human in the loop. Make sure you are that human, and better at it than the rest, by tinkering with it yourself.
That is advice for individuals, though, not a solution for the industry.
What remains
I don't believe you should hand any function over to AI entirely. Every field needs someone in the loop who understands it. And people who know enough to steer other functions as well become more valuable, not less. That is where there is a place for communications people. But that place isn't waiting for them. You have to claim it, at a table where others are now sitting. That calls for raising the bar considerably.
What will remain of our profession, I don't know. But I do know where you won't find the answer: at a conference where we tell each other how important we are.
High satisfaction scores are nice. But a contented audience is not a profession with a future.
Sources:
