This year I took Mark Ritson’s Mini MBA in Brand Management. Over my career I had seen plenty of brand models and strategy sessions come and go, but one thing really stuck. It starts with the first question Ritson asks a new client: when does your financial year start?
An odd opening question for a brand strategist, you might think. But he is simply counting backwards. When are budgets approved? When does the plan have to be on the table? When is the strategy locked? And so: when does the research need to be finished, and when do you have to start it? The last question on his list is what today’s date is. And then it often turns out you are already too late.
Diagnosis, strategy, execution
According to Ritson, good brand strategy consists of three steps, in this order: diagnosis, strategy and execution. First find out where things really stand, then choose what you are going to do, and only then start making things. It sounds obvious, but in practice many organisations start at the end. There has to be a campaign, a new tagline or a rebrand, and the brief is already written before anyone has asked what is actually going on. As a PR agency, I spent years on the receiving end of briefs like that.
Why do so many organisations skip the diagnosis? In his course, Ritson lists four forces working against it: experience, salary, power and the assumption that you already know your brand. The longer you work somewhere, the more you earn and the higher up you are, the less you think you need to investigate. Against all that stands just one thing, and that is time. Or rather, the lack of it.
Our ancestors were not idiots
The part of the diagnosis I learned the most from is not about surveys or data, although those definitely belong in it. It is about the past. Ritson starts a diagnosis with where a brand comes from, with its history and its founders. Dig into the archives, find old advertising, read the original documents and look for things that once worked and have since been forgotten. One of his slides puts it very drily: our ancestors were not idiots.
That is quite a dig at our profession. Every new marketing director wants to leave their own mark, and every new agency comes with its own idea. The fact that someone, twenty years ago, thought very carefully about what makes this brand special tends to get lost along the way.
Toyota came up in the course. Research showed that consumers saw Asian car brands largely as one big group, so Toyota lacked distinctiveness. Part of the answer came from going back to what the founders had once written down. The principles from back then turned out to be as useful as ever.
Cool versus hot
A nice Dutch example is Coolblue, an online retailer I saw up close for years. The name was a reaction to Hot Orange, the hip Amsterdam internet company of the time. Coolblue wanted to be the exact opposite: down to earth, Rotterdam, practical. The founders also made an agreement among themselves that sounds almost banal: they wanted to make good money with a great service company.
That did not come out of a positioning session. It was a conviction, and you still see it in the customer service, the tone, the humour and the culture. That is why the brand doesn’t feel invented, but lived.
Born out of irritation
Brands are remarkably often born out of irritation with how an industry works. When Jody and I started our agency Coopr, we mostly wanted to do everything differently from the rest of the PR world. Less secrecy, less polished corporate communication and less good behaviour. Make a bit more noise and have an opinion about things. It was not a worked-out brand story, more a feeling of: why does everyone actually do this the same way?
Looking back, that is where the foundation of a brand lies. Many organisations think positioning starts with a strategy session, but usually it simply starts with something the founders were annoyed by or truly believed in.
Not nostalgia
Going back to your origins does not mean making a retro campaign with old photos of the founder, by the way. In Ritson’s list, history is only the start of the diagnosis. After that come existing data, observation, conversations with your most loyal customers, focus groups and a solid quantitative survey. The past tells you what was once distinctive about your brand. The research tells you how much of that still lives with your customers today.
So
Before anyone calls an agency for a campaign: start digging. Find the old ads, read the interviews with the founders, talk to the colleague who has been there for twenty years and to the customers who have been loyal for years. Very often the answer is already there, right at the beginning.
And plan for it. If your strategy has to be locked in September, August is too late for a proper diagnosis.
Now, when does your financial year start?
